What’s self-incrimination?

Print anything with Printful



Self-incrimination is when a person accuses themselves of a crime. The Fifth Amendment in the US allows people to refuse to testify if it could result in self-incrimination. Immunity or plea deals can be offered to alleviate concerns. People may also incriminate themselves through direct admission, questioning in court, or while under arrest. It’s important to remain silent and seek legal advice.

When people are accused of a crime, it is often someone else or some other agency who has made the accusation. In most cases, people do not voluntarily accuse themselves of a crime or say things that would make others think they are criminally responsible, called self-incrimination. When a person incriminates himself, he accuses himself. This term is often used in the context of adopting the Fifth Amendment or refusing to speak to avoid self-indictment.

The U.S. Fifth Amendment is a right under which in most cases people can refuse to testify if the testimony results in self-incrimination. By law, people must testify against themselves; they may refrain from speaking, again, most of the time, if what they have to say could result in criminal charges being brought against them. This becomes particularly useful when people are asked to testify against another who may reveal their illegal activities; instead they reply that they refuse to talk because it could incriminate them, or they can simply state that they take the Fifth.

There are several methods to obtain the testimony of someone concerned about self-incrimination. A prosecutor may be able to create a plea deal for the person testifying. In this pact, admitting the crime committed would not result in prosecution or result in a reduction of charges.

In the first instance we speak of the granting of immunity. A firm offer of immunity could allay a witness’ concerns that his testimony is self-incriminating. He could then admit to a crime in court without worrying about the charges. It should be noted that this immunity offer would need to be approved by the witness’s attorney; much weaker offers could be made which would still cause the witness to incriminate themselves and could lead to criminal charges.

Someone on trial may also incriminate themselves, either through direct admission of guilt and filing a guilty plea, or through questioning in court. In many circumstances an accused person does not have to testify and lawyers may advise against doing so. This is a common question in movies, TV, and books with legal themes: Will he accidentally or intentionally incriminate himself if the defendant testifies?

Another instance where people might practice self-incrimination is while under arrest or in the custody of legal officials. People have the right to remain silent and say that whatever they say “can and will” be used against them in court. Despite prodigious advice from lawyers to fully vindicate this right to silence, many people speak up and can end up implicating themselves in a crime by their statements. It’s not entirely clear what pleas of guilt and innocence are during police interrogations, but people should be fully aware that anything they say can be turned into an accusation of themselves.




Protect your devices with Threat Protection by NordVPN


Skip to content