The US Constitution provided a mechanism for amending the Constitution as needed. The 16th Amendment clarified Congress’s authority to levy taxes on income, without apportionment among states. Prior to its ratification, there was confusion about whether income taxes were direct or indirect taxes. The tax amendment ended this debate by stating that all income is indirect income and need not be apportioned among states.
The US Constitution sets out the guiding principles upon which the United States of America was founded. While the Constitution covered a staggering amount of ground, even the Founding Father knew that the future was likely to require changes to the Constitution and, therefore, provided a forward-looking mechanism for amending the Constitution. The question of taxation is an issue which, although mentioned in the Constitution, has required an amendment to clarify the role of taxes in the United States. The 16th Amendment to the Constitution was called the “Tax Amendment” because it finally clarified questions about Congress’s authority to levy taxes and how those taxes can be levied.
The tax amendment reads as follows: “Congress shall have power to levy and collect taxes on income, from whatever source it arises, without apportionment among the states, and without regard to any census or enumeration.” Ratified in 1913, the tax amendment finally silenced the debate about whether income taxes are direct or indirect taxes and, therefore, whether or not they should be apportioned among states. Prior to the ratification of the 16th Amendment, a number of Congressional acts and Supreme Court cases focused on the question of whether income taxes were direct or indirect taxes, with varying results. Congress finally settled the matter by ratifying the tax amendment.
The concept of income tax was originally introduced as a way to provide revenue for the Civil War. A number of tax acts have imposed a flat income tax on income above a certain threshold. At the time, income taxes were regarded as indirect taxes and, therefore, the only requirement was that they were levied with geographical uniformity. A Supreme Court decision, however, in Pollock v. Farmers’ Loan & Trust Co. in 1895 ruled that some income taxes were in fact direct taxes and “must be apportioned among the various states according to population.” After Pollock, the source of income became the deciding factor in whether a tax was considered a direct or indirect tax.
As a result of the income tax confusion and controversy, the tax amendment was introduced as the 16th Amendment to the Constitution in 1909. The amendment ended, once and for all, the debate about whether to consider the source of income and whether the income taxes are direct or indirect taxes. The tax amendment clearly states that all income is indirect income and, therefore, need not be apportioned among states.
Protect your devices with Threat Protection by NordVPN
